Coleman was a member of the College’s Golf Team from 1970-1974. In 1973 he was the winner of the All New England Sectional Tournament (College Division NAIA’s), he played in the National NAIA College Championships in Greenville, South Carolina. He also played in the National NCAA Championships in Riverside, California, where he finished in the top 25 and received All-American Honorable Mention. In 1972-73 he was voted team MVP. In 1973-74 he was the winner of the New England Small College Tournament at Wabeeka Springs Golf Course, at which time he was voted team MVP again and was captain of the team.